Ars Technica·3 min read

Polygraphs have major flaws. Are there better options?

Polygraphs face scrutiny over reliability and accuracy

George W. Maschke's experience with a failed FBI polygraph in 1995, despite a prior security clearance, spurred him to investigate the reliability of polygraphs, leading to the creation of AntiPolygraph.org. His findings, supported by scientific research, highlight significant flaws in polygraph testing, including high rates of false positives and negatives, which undermine their use in law enforcement and security clearances.

Key Takeaways

  • 1.

    Polygraphs accurately identify guilty individuals only 75% of the time.

  • 2.

    Research shows polygraphs misjudge truth-tellers just 57% of the time.

  • 3.

    Innocent individuals are often at a disadvantage during polygraph tests.

Get your personalized feed

Trace groups the biggest stories, videos, and discussions into one feed so you can stay current without scanning ten tabs.

Try Trace free
Polygraphs have major flaws. Are there better options? | Trace